Author
| anybody cloned OCM?
|
dproldan msx friend Posts: 4 | Posted: March 24 2009, 21:26   |
Hello all
I've been taking a look at all the information about the OCM. I was surprised to find the schematics, a PCB drawing and the needed files to program the FPGA chip. With that information and some relatively trivial work somebody with experience could actually build the OCM without much trouble.
Hasn't anybody tried to replicate it? Do you think ESE artist factory (If I'm not mistaken they designed this) has opposed any plans to build new ones?
Thanks for your input
D.
|
|
NYYRIKKI msx master Posts: 1805 | Posted: March 24 2009, 22:47   |
|
|
zogo msx friend Posts: 3 | Posted: March 25 2009, 10:02   |
@dproldan: Could you post where you found these documents?
|
|
dhau msx master Posts: 1384 | Posted: March 25 2009, 10:10   |
To topic starter:
Yes, all the plans are freely available. As mentioned by NYYRIKKI above, caro adjusted ESE MSX System 3 VHDL code to run on Altera DE1 board, even with some improvements (DE1 = 20K logic gates and 16 bit DAC, ESE MSX System 3 = 12K logic gates and 1 bit DAC).
No, no one tried to fully clone ESE MSX System 3, including PCB layout, slot connectors and nice plastic case, because that would probably cost 10x more then the selling price of still widely available ESE MSX System 3 even without the plastic case.
Any other amazingly bright ideas that surprizingly no one esle came up with before you?
|
|
spl msx professional Posts: 813 | Posted: March 25 2009, 10:13   |
Although I have an original 1chipMSX, I have a question: how do you flash the FPGA of the DE1 board for the first time?
|
|
NYYRIKKI msx master Posts: 1805 | Posted: March 25 2009, 10:35   |
@spl DE1 has built in JTAG
|
|
spl msx professional Posts: 813 | Posted: March 25 2009, 10:56   |
Ok. Thanks for the info.
|
|
dproldan msx friend Posts: 4 | Posted: March 25 2009, 13:28   |
@Nyyrikki Thanks for pointing out the DE1 system.
@dhau thanks for your answer, even with the sarcastic tone.
The idea does't look "amazingly bright" to me; what amazes me is that, having almost all the information, nobody has tried to replicate the hardware. Different groups have built high quality boards for the MSX, so the knowledge is here. I supposed that there must be something else preventing this from happening.
You're price estimation is wrong. A quick BOM and some search tells me materials would cost about 120 USD on a prototyping scale, excluding the case. In Europe, a small EMS would charge something between 20-30 EUR for the assembly. If you add a generic box cutted with a router, another 15-25 EUR. It would add to 170-180 EUR maximum.
I guess I'll have to ask ESE directly about this.
D.
|
|
Ivan
 msx master Posts: 1167 | Posted: March 25 2009, 15:45   |
|
|
spl msx professional Posts: 813 | Posted: March 27 2009, 11:26   |
At June I will get a DE1 board to do some tests  (even it doesn't have joy or cart ports  ) |
|
Ivan
 msx master Posts: 1167 | Posted: March 27 2009, 13:52   |
Is Altera's DE1 inspired by the OCM?  |
|
dhau msx master Posts: 1384 | Posted: March 27 2009, 14:47   |
Quote:
| Is Altera's DE1 inspired by the OCM? 
|
Absolutely! And MSX is inspired my Metal Gear. |
|
Ivan
 msx master Posts: 1167 | Posted: March 27 2009, 14:50   |
|
|
Alex msx lover Posts: 124 | Posted: March 29 2009, 14:19   |
The design of the OCM is indeed free. Anybody who wishes to can produce one and even sell it. Though, you can't sell one with an image of the MSX-ROMS included because the MSX-ROMS are not free. You will have to negotiate a license with the current license holders if you want to produce and sell an OCM that comes with an image of the MSX-ROMS bundled in the package.
|
|
Ivan
 msx master Posts: 1167 | Posted: March 29 2009, 14:29   |
As spl pointed out the Altera DE1 board might be an alternative, but the OCM does have cartridge slots, an enclosed case and better SW support from ESE and the MSX community.
|
|
|
|
|